Showing posts with label Bailout Proposal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bailout Proposal. Show all posts

Friday, October 3, 2008

PIRATE ECONOMICS

The pirates off the coast of Somalia got it wrong. They should have gone to Wall Street. It's much easier to board and loot treasure when you trash an economy, threaten meltdown and depression, and then lobby Congress for your loot. No wonder Congress put in earmarks for Rum ... they needed the pirate vote.
The House caved in and approved the bailout measure on the second try. Incredible.


Look, at the end of the day, this vote was a pathetic cave-in to Wall Street and their threats of insolvency. And it did little to nothing to punish the culprits behind this bailout mess.

Tonight I'm going to go spend money and drink until I find an eye patch to put on. Then I'll put my daughter's parakeet on my shoulder for effect. Arrrghhhh ...

- Mark

Thursday, October 2, 2008

OK, I WOULDN'T VOTE FOR THE SENATE'S BAILOUT BILL. HERE'S WHY ... (Part I)

Last night, after taking a quick look at the Senate bailout version I wrote that, in spite of the pork included, I might support the bill if I were in the House of Representatives. There's too much at stake (and there is). However, after getting a closer look, I have to say that I would not support this bill. Before I provide the specifics - which I will do in my next post - we need some history.

In a few words, what we are being asked to bailout is a market environment that is no longer focused on the production of goods & services. What we have in front of is, and what helped create this mess, is a market driven by gamblers bent on extracting wealth. The Senate bill not only fails to punish what can only be called 'pirate economics', it pretty much rewards it.

A little bit of history helps us understand my thinking here, and how we got to this point. I'll address the specifics of the Senate bill in my next post. The following is from Chapter 4 of my forthcoming book, The Roots of Markets & Wealth ...

In A Short History of Financial Euphoria, John Kenneth Galbraith discusses the famous case of “Tulipomania” in Amsterdam at the beginning of the seventeenth century. What started as simple prestige for those who possessed novel tulip bulbs turned into wild speculation over successive price increases throughout 1636. Specifically, competition over tulips turned into mania, with single bulbs trading for new carriages and homes, or fetching as much as $25-50,000 each. Demand reached such heights the Amsterdam Stock Exchange developed a futures market for the bulb. 
This market, as well as the dreams of many speculators, would collapse under the weight of its own nonsense and spectacular avarice. As sellers demanded their tulip contracts be enforced, they were disappointed when their petitions fell on the deaf ears of the courts. Because the market had little to do with the production of actual goods and services, the courts viewed Tulipomania as little more than a gambling operation. As is the case throughout these histories, panic, default, and bankruptcy followed. Galbraith wrote “no one knows for what reason” the speculation and mania ended, but there’s little doubt common sense finally prevailed in a market spun out of control by deluded buyers and sellers. 
Fast forward almost 340 years. We find the creation of another futures market, but this time in U.S. dollars. In The Vandal’s Crown: How Rebel Currency Traders Overthrew the World’s Central Banks, Gregory J. Millman tells the story of how a glut of U.S. dollars (see Chapters 10 & 11) helped turn the world’s anchor currency into another commodity, just like corn and beef. Driven by the need to pay for the defense of the West, while attempting to solve social problems at home, by the mid-1960s the U.S. government had put too many dollars into circulation. Because too much of anything drives down its value traders knew the future price of the dollar would both fluctuate and drop, especially with persistent U.S. budget deficits and growing debt.

Like all good entrepreneurs traders wanted to profit off of these dynamics but needed to go beyond what traders in the Euro-Currency markets were doing (trading currencies to cover commercial transactions). They wanted to trade dollar futures. By 1970 they were looking to trade and speculate on the dollar like Chicago Mercantile dealers who bought and sold pork bellies and cattle. To do this, they needed to convince the Nixon administration that speculating on the value of the dollar was a good thing. They would say nothing about what made trading on the dollar so profitable – the underlying irresponsibility of bloated budgets, growing debt, and price fixing.

For $5,000 (paid by traders) Milton Friedman was goaded into writing a paper which argued that a futures market in dollars was a good idea. Friedman would ignore the underlying irresponsibility of bloated budgets and growing debt. Friedman’s paper was sent to Nixon’s Treasury Secretary, George Schultz, who bought into the idea, stating “…if it’s good enough for Milton [Friedman], it’s good enough for me.”

The result was an explosion in currency trading and other “innovative” financial instruments whose value now outpaces the value of goods and services produced around the world. Today, an entire industry of traders, analysts, and lawyers make their living off of what Peter F. Drucker called a “symbolic economy” (discussed in Chapter 11). Ignored is how little the average person understands this part of the economy, and how bloated budgets and growing debt feed it. Also left unaddressed – if not conveniently ignored – is how continued deficit spending and bloated budgets virtually insure the precipitous decline of the dollar. These dynamics fly in the face of what Adam Smith had to say about the importance of knowledge, transparency, and information in capitalist markets.

Given these cases (and there are more), do we simply trust all market players to do what’s right and not succumb to speculation, greed, and the herd mentality that overtook Holland’s tulip traders? If history – and current events – has taught us anything it’s this: The further a generation gets from the great financial disasters of the past the more their confidence grows in the brilliant and innovative discoveries they’ve made in the markets of their day. Past experiences and skeptics - as JK Galbraith put it - are “dismissed as the primitive refuge of those who do not have the insight to appreciate” what the new wonderkinds have fashioned ...

- Mark

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

THERE'S NO PUTTING LIPSTICK ON THIS PIG

If the House Republicans didn't like the bailout proposal they rejected on Monday, they're going to love what the Senate just passed. There's stuff for education, credits for steel industry fuel, stuff on the alternative minimum tax, energy credits, and additional oil industry tax breaks.

I guess these guys can't help themselves ... it's not like there's an emergency going on. The Senate, however, did put stuff in that would deal with the financial mess we're in. Good for them. Then they patted themselves on the back (profusely, I might add) for doing what we were all taught in kindergarten - to work together.

If House Republicans stood on principle in rejecting the proposal on Monday we can expect them to reject this Senate bailout proposal out of hand, right? Then what? But if the House Republicans cave in, and vote for this bill, what does it say about their principles?

Incredibly, I'm not sure I would vote against this bill if I were in the House of Representatives. The longer market uncertainty persists the easier it is for events to escape human control ...

I'm still reading through this 431 page (up from 109 pages) bill. Stay tuned.

- Mark

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

WILL THE DEREGULATION STUPIDITY NEVER END?

Here’s an article written by Newt Gingrich in Forbes.com. It's not his best work ...

Newt’s trying to set a story-line that suggests the market collapse we’re seeing today is a result of faulty regulations, and not underlying structural problems. In a few words, he’s saying don’t just look at collapsed prices. Think about what you could get for financial instruments if the markets were fine. To fix the problem Newt’s calling for another set of accounting standards because … well, it will help fix market prices.

Let’s see. At the end of each day, financial instruments are valued at the price they can fetch out on the open market … and that's a bad thing? It is according to Newt Gingrich. Here’s Newt’s explanation (Mumbo-Jumbo Fair Warning ... skip to the next paragraph, for my translation):

Because existing rules requiring mark-to-market accounting are causing such turmoil on Wall Street, mark-to-market accounting should be suspended immediately so as to relieve the stress on banks and corporations. In the interim, we can use the economic value approach based on a discounted cash flow analysis of anticipated-income streams, as we did for decades before the new mark-to-market began to take hold. We can take the time to evaluate mark-to-market all over again. Perhaps a three-year rolling average to determine mark-to-market prices would be a workable permanent system … It is not widely understood that the adoption of mark-to-market accounting rules is a major factor in the liquidity crisis which is leading companies to go bankrupt. But it is destructive to have artificial accounting rules ruin companies that would have otherwise survived under previous rules.
Got that? Don't worry. I've put this through my "Newt B.S. 'O Meter." Here’s the English language translation ...

Newt Gingich wants to change the rules so we can revalue all the ugly financial instruments that are currently worth 20-30 cents on the dollar (if that). He thinks we should value these financial instruments on a three year average. You know, so the financial instruments, and the financial institutions holding them, don’t have to suffer the consequences of “impaired” values of a collapsed market. Best of all, no one gets their feelings hurt because they're sitting on trash (OK, I threw in that last one).

If you’re still having trouble getting a hold on Newt’s proposal, let’s try this. Assume you own a home with an average value of approximately $500,000 over the past three years. Today, the home is worth $325,000. According to Gingrich’s logic you should be able to value your home according to its three year average.

This might be enticing (and exciting) if Newt was talking about your home. However, Newt’s not talking about your home. He’s talking about the market instruments that got us into this mess! Under Newt’s plan the value of your home will still be sucking wind. And the market instruments that got us into this mess? Well, they’ll start going up.

But don’t worry, says the Newtster. Once the big guys start making money, the markets will stabilize, so you’ll win in the long run (if you've heard that story before you're not alone).

But let’s assume Newt was talking about the value of our homes. Can you imagine going to your bank, and then saying “How about an equity loan? My house is worth $325,000 on the market … but the average value has been $500,000 … so give me $100,000 … even though I'm up-side down and owe $400,000.” Or, can you imagine turning over your $325,000 house to the bank and telling them "It’s worth $500,000, so pay me the difference"? Better yet … well, you get the picture.

Does this make sense to you? It does to Newt, and a whole bunch of republicans too. And it’s all proposed in the name of deregulation … you know, to help markets function better.

This is the kind of republican-led deregulation proposal that got us into the market mess in the first place. Rather than look at the real problem (poor oversight, greed, and stupidity) Newt Gingrich wants to do some creative accounting …

And here’s the kicker. CFO.com is telling us that the nations’ chief financial officers are saying we don’t need Newt’s plan. A couple of turns of the screws have already helped.

Worst of all for Newt is that the investment community actually like the bailout plan. They also reject the notion of suspending current accounting methods - which Newt wants to do - because rock bottom prices will keep the government from paying too much for garbage in a bailout. They're actually looking out for America's financial interests.

I wonder who Newt's lobbying for these days ...

- Mark

Monday, September 29, 2008

WHAT A MESS ...

Congress rejected the bailout proposal with 228-205 vote and market players are starting to panic. When it became clear what was going on in Washington the Dow dropped almost 700 points ...

Here's how our representatives voted: Rep. Jim Costa, YES; Rep. Kevin McCarthy, NO.

Here's what we have: Republicans killed the deal ... George W. Bush no longer has any influence over his party ... John McCain's "return to Washington" publicity stunt has been exposed for being just that, a publicity stunt ... the global market MSCI index has tanked 5.9%, the steepest decline in its 38 year history ... and global market players are so spooked that the Fed appears to be taking matters into their own hands ...

What a mess. Stay tuned.

- Mark

Saturday, September 27, 2008

BAILOUT HUMOR

While bailout politics is serious stuff, this TT comic captures the moment ...


As usual, if you can't read the font, click on the comic.

- Mark

Friday, September 26, 2008

THE PAULSON-BUSH PLAN

For those of you who haven't seen Secretary Paulson's blank check bailout proposal, here it is. I've italicized key points of interest.


LEGISLATIVE PROPOSAL FOR TREASURY AUTHORITY

TO PURCHASE MORTGAGE-RELATED ASSETS

Section 1. Short Title.

This Act may be cited as ____________________.

Sec. 2. Purchases of Mortgage-Related Assets.

(a) Authority to Purchase.--The Secretary is authorized to purchase, and to make and fund commitments to purchase, on such terms and conditions as determined by the Secretary, mortgage-related assets from any financial institution having its headquarters in the United States.

(b) Necessary Actions.--The Secretary is authorized to take such actions as the Secretary deems necessary to carry out the authorities in this Act, including, without limitation:

(1) appointing such employees as may be required to carry out the authorities in this Act and defining their duties;

(2) entering into contracts, including contracts for services authorized by section 3109 of title 5, United States Code, without regard to any other provision of law regarding public contracts;

(3) designating financial institutions as financial agents of the Government, and they shall perform all such reasonable duties related to this Act as financial agents of the Government as may be required of them;

(4) establishing vehicles that are authorized, subject to supervision by the Secretary, to purchase mortgage-related assets and issue obligations; and

(5) issuing such regulations and other guidance as may be necessary or appropriate to define terms or carry out the authorities of this Act.

Sec. 3. Considerations.

In exercising the authorities granted in this Act, the Secretary shall take into consideration means for--

(1) providing stability or preventing disruption to the financial markets or banking system; and

(2) protecting the taxpayer.

Sec. 4. Reports to Congress.

Within three months of the first exercise of the authority granted in section 2(a), and semiannually thereafter, the Secretary shall report to the Committees on the Budget, Financial Services, and Ways and Means of the House of Representatives and the Committees on the Budget, Finance, and Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs of the Senate with respect to the authorities exercised under this Act and the considerations required by section 3.

Sec. 5. Rights; Management; Sale of Mortgage-Related Assets.

(a) Exercise of Rights.--The Secretary may, at any time, exercise any rights received in connection with mortgage-related assets purchased under this Act.

(b) Management of Mortgage-Related Assets.--The Secretary shall have authority to manage mortgage-related assets purchased under this Act, including revenues and portfolio risks therefrom.

(c) Sale of Mortgage-Related Assets.--The Secretary may, at any time, upon terms and conditions and at prices determined by the Secretary, sell, or enter into securities loans, repurchase transactions or other financial transactions in regard to, any mortgage-related asset purchased under this Act.

(d) Application of Sunset to Mortgage-Related Assets.--The authority of the Secretary to hold any mortgage-related asset purchased under this Act before the termination date in section 9, or to purchase or fund the purchase of a mortgage-related asset under a commitment entered into before the termination date in section 9, is not subject to the provisions of section 9.

Sec. 6. Maximum Amount of Authorized Purchases.

The Secretary’s authority to purchase mortgage-related assets under this Act shall be limited to $700,000,000,000 outstanding at any one time.

Sec. 7. Funding.

For the purpose of the authorities granted in this Act, and for the costs of administering those authorities, the Secretary may use the proceeds of the sale of any securities issued under chapter 31 of title 31, United States Code, and the purposes for which securities may be issued under chapter 31 of title 31, United States Code, are extended to include actions authorized by this Act, including the payment of administrative expenses. Any funds expended for actions authorized by this Act, including the payment of administrative expenses, shall be deemed appropriated at the time of such expenditure.

Sec. 8. Review.

Decisions by the Secretary pursuant to the authority of this Act are non-reviewable and committed to agency discretion, and may not be reviewed by any court of law or any administrative agency.

Sec. 9. Termination of Authority.

The authorities under this Act, with the exception of authorities granted in sections 2(b)(5), 5 and 7, shall terminate two years from the date of enactment of this Act.

Sec. 10. Increase in Statutory Limit on the Public Debt.

Subsection (b) of section 3101 of title 31, United States Code, is amended by striking out the dollar limitation contained in such subsection and inserting in lieu thereof $11,315,000,000,000.

Sec. 11. Credit Reform.

The costs of purchases of mortgage-related assets made under section 2(a) of this Act shall be determined as provided under the Federal Credit Reform Act of 1990, as applicable.

Sec. 12. Definitions.

For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:

(1) Mortgage-Related Assets.--The term “mortgage-related assets” means residential or commercial mortgages and any securities, obligations, or other instruments that are based on or related to such mortgages, that in each case was originated or issued on or before September 17, 2008.

(2) Secretary.--The term “Secretary” means the Secretary of the Treasury.

(3) United States.--The term “United States” means the States, territories, and possessions of the United States and the District of Columbia.

Thursday, September 25, 2008

THESE GUYS ARE IDIOTS

Earlier today I wrote that the republicans want to (1) rebuke President Bush publicly and (2) gut Obama's "Protect the Taxpayers and Homeowners" provision. Well, it looks like it's worse than that.

According to CNNMoney.com the republicans are proposing an Economic Rescue Principles plan that, incredibly enough, removes "regulatory and tax barriers that are currently blocking private capital formation." Put another way, they want tax breaks and more deregulation. You can read their proposal here.

I don't know if anyone has told these guys, but tax breaks for the rich and deregulation are what got us into this mess. What's really blocking private capital formation is fear ... fear of each other's stupidity eating into their profits. This is why banks and financial institutions are not lending to each other - in spite of hundreds of billions in FED-laced loans & credit.

Still, to get this arrangement republicans are offering to have the private sector pay an insurance premium to make sure their mortgage backed securities (MBS) will pay off. How nice of them.

Here's the problem. The proposal has the federal government insuring about half of the MBS market, with the private sector insuring the other half.

Gee, I wonder which half the government gets to insure?

In essence, the republican proposal says to the taxpayer, "You guys stabilize the markets (for $350 billion), and make sure they work, and we'll step in and throw a capitalist party ... as long as you give us some more deregulation and tax breaks."

These guys not only want to rebuke Bush, and eviscerate Obama's proposal, but they want to start the game all over.

These guys are idiots. And they're banking on America being full of a bunch of idiots too ... as is John McCain.

- Mark

BAILOUT POLITICS ... CLEAR THE VOMITORIUM

So I'm flipping through the channels trying to determine whether anyone is reporting that the Bush administration will get their bailout proposal. This morning it looked like the Democrats got some of their concerns addressed, which had the press discussing a bailout bill that could be voted on today or tomorrow. Suddenly, John McCain is air-dropped in, and just like that it looks like there will be no bailout any time soon.

Right now the press is blaming Republican Minority Leader, John Boehner, especially since it appears he agreed to many of the provisions that are now being rejected beforehand. Here's what many people see ...

1. President Bush has little or no influence within his party.

2. John McCain has little or no influence on events.

Then we have the real world.

Obama was eating McCain's lunch the past two weeks. Sarah Palin was looking like a bit player from the movie FARGO. Their poll numbers were slumping. What we have going on today is a major game of political theater playing out between John McCain, John Boehner and the American taxpayer. The prize? The American presidency.

Everyone knows that Paulson and the president want their plan. Everyone knows Boehner prefers something that guts Obama's proposals (an equity stake in firms for the American taxpayer, CEO pay limits, homeowner relief, and bi-partisan oversight panel). This is where John McCain comes in.

By having McCain show up, Boehner has his trump card. McCain's "Drama Queen Politics" distracts the press from Boehner backing away from an agreed upon plan. Keep in mind the press is on McCain like white on rice (or incompetence on Bush). This works for the republicans because they can show that they don't support a lame duck and highly unpopular president's bailout proposal. They can now angle for something that will weaken Obama's proposals. McCain and the republicans steal the show.

But here's the good part. No one is discussing how low McCain is falling in the polls, or how unprepared Sarah Palin is. And it gets better. No one has the time to start talking about what's slowly making its way into the news ... John McCain and his role in the Keating 5.

Obama hasn't spoken at this time, so I hope he comes out and (1) publicly calls John McCain and President Bush out for their inability to get their guys in line and (2) for orchestrating what's amounted to a White House photo-op.

My friends, this is beyond "Silly Season." It's Bread & Circus in the best tradition of Rome. Clear the way to the vomitorium ...

- Mark

DRAMA QUEEN POLITICS

Apart from President Bush's "scare-mongering-to-sell-my-bailout" speech last night, there's another issue voters need to keep in mind.

Since the credit/financial market problems emerged on the political scene we have watched John McCain have his own meltdown. He has done the following:

1. Claimed "market fundamentals" are sound ... and then unilaterally changed what "fundamentals" mean.

2. Claimed he was against a bailout for AIG ... before he was for it.

3. Suggested he would fire SEC Chair Christopher Cox ... who is only remotely connected to this mess, and can't be fired by the president.

4. Suspended his very serious presidential campaign because things are, well, so serious ... in the process proving he can't multi-task.

5. Called for postponing the first presidential debate ... because his polling numbers are tanking.

Keep in mind that all of this occurred after McCain panicked and picked Caribou Barbie as his VP running mate. For added measure, after calling for a bailout McCain has said he might not vote for the bailout proposal (but he did say this in a decisive manner, mind you).

Let's not mince words: Temperament counts as much as judgment. McCain has neither.

John McCain is an unstable Drama Queen, and unfit to lead.

- Mark

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

BUSH'S 14 MINUTE CAMEO

Here's a few comments on George Bush's 14 minute cameo appearance ...

Bush tried to explain everything that's gone wrong in the markets in real simple terms. This is hard enough to do when you understand what's going on. Bush clearly has no idea what's happening. His blank "reading-the-teleprompter" eyes made this clear. Still there are several things to cull from Bush's appearance.

THE ISSUE(S): With President Bush's "our entire economy is in danger" observation he efectively said "We're in trouble and we have no money in credit markets because people got greedy and stupid." He used his standard M.O. to get America and Congress to support his Paulson-escorted bailout plan; i.e. "Be Afraid Because Worse May Be Around the Corner."

HOW DID WE REACH THIS POINT?: President Bush tried to explain what's happened with reference to easy money (created by funds from abroad and low interest rates) and the emergence of toxic mortgage backed securities (MBS, a form of CDOs, which I posted on below). He then tried to pin blame on house flippers. Conveniently, Bush said nothing about a culture of debt, tax breaks, and deregulation.

What really happened? Effectively, the same people he dumped tax breaks on ran the economy into the ground.

HOW WILL THE PLAN WORK?: President Bush effectively said "By bailing out stupid and greedy people with my plan we remove the risk from the market, for now."

In an 8 year span of self-serving and pathetic moments, this was one of his worst.

WHAT ABOUT OUR ECONOMIC FUTURE?: President Bush pretty much told us, "Don't worry, the government has your back." Everything else he said means nothing.

At the end of the day, Bush missed an opportunity to look presidential. He could have said, "We were wrong ... I was wrong, forgive me." Instead, he said "Give me the money so I am remembered only as a blundering General George Custer, and not as a floundering Herbert Hoover too."

- Mark

THIS IS NUTS ... WHY THE BAILOUT PROPOSAL NEEDS TO BE REJECTED

While everyone in Congress is rightly concerned with the provision in the Treasury Department's $700 billion bail-out proposal that tells us decisions made "are non-reviewable ... and may not be reviewed by any court of law or any administrative agency" there are additional reasons to reject the Bush administration's bailout proposal.

Page one of the proposal tells us the Treasury Secretary can enter into contracts "without regard to any other provisions of law regarding public contracts" and can designate "financial institutions as financial agents of the Government." According to the bailout proposal Secretary Paulson can do this, and pretty much whatever else he wants, "without limitation."

While the above is pretty clear, it's Bush/Finance-speak for "We make the rules, and will appoint our buddies to do whatever we want ... and the courts can't review any of the wrong-doing that went on either ..."

But here's the real kick in the teeth: "The Secretary's authority to purchase mortgage-related assets under this Act shall be limited to $700,0000,000,000 outstanding at any one time. With this one sentence, this much is clear: $700 billion is the first installment.

This blank check bailout proposal needs to be rejected, today.

- Mark

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

CHICKEN LITTLE RIDES AGAIN ...

Fed Chair Ben S. Bernanke is urging Congress to grant the U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson Czar-like authority to do what he wants with $700 billion of taxpayer money. This includes purchasing financial toxic waste at more than generous levels. Here's Paulson on the dangers we face:


"I believe if the credit markets are not functioning, that jobs will be lost, the unemployment rate will rise, more houses will be foreclosed upon, GDP will contract, that the economy will just not be able to recover ..."

If Congress doesn't play along both Bernanke and Paulson say the financial sky will fall.

Guess what? I'm more concerned with this happening again. Unless Congress addresses how debt & deregulation feed stupidity and greed, Paulson's bailout proposal only postpones what's happening into the next administration.

Bailout - and Bailout Now - is not the solution. I say fix this, and fix it now.

- Mark